While this, too, eliminated an historic source of favoritism, it also 
tended to equalize the income of the gang men. Constant attention 
was paid to the relative work opportunity of hall and gang men, but
an equalization was in large measure maintained simply by the
men exercising their option of working either in a gang or from
the hall.

The hiring hall was indeed "the union." It was the institution
whereby the reality of community could be fashioned and
maintained by men who had agreed to structure and divide their
work on a fair and equal basis and who, through great strife and
conflict, had won the right to do so. As for the on-going fairness
of the dispatch system, that was to be insured by the men
annually electing their representatives to the joint Labor
Relations and Promotions committees from their own ranks. An
annual election of dispatchers by and from the ranks was also to
assure the honesty and fairness of its day-to-day operation.

The Dialogue.. A centralized "sign-in" and dispatch for work
and the physical existence of a hiring hall meant that over a
period of time the hall men became very well acquainted. Their
acquaintance was also reinforced when they were dispatched to
the same gang, ship, or dock. Since hall men were dispatched
"to fill out the gangs" with needed men, acquaintances between
the hall and gang men also developed over time. The men of
different gangs were likewise destined to become acquainted by
being dispatched to the same ship and, not infrequently, by
having been assigned to opposite ends of the same hatch. With
the passage of time, then, most of the San Francisco longshoremen 
had developed at least some acquaintanceship with all of
their union brothers. The average longshoreman was also
destined to become very well acquainted with a considerable
number of those men.5 For most men, such acquaintanceships
frequently grew into a real and lasting friendship. Friendships
were also spawned and strengthened over breakfast at the many
waterfront cafes, at "the coffee break," with a deck of cards at
lunch, and when the men were "sent to supper" prior to
finishing a vessel (this continued until 1966). 
next page previous page first page home